Table 5a.

Heterogenous Impacts for VT Program, 6 months Mongolian VT Program, 2014–2016

Employment 6-monthEarnings 6-monthSkills match 6-monthSelf-employment 6-month
ITTTOTITTTOTITTTOTITTTOT
VT Program(0.056)(0.132)(46,984)(110,833*)(0.048)(0.114)(0.016)(0.041)
(0.043)(0.096)(29,500)(65,876)(0.036)(0.079)(0.021)(0.047)
Males0.157***0.156**213,390***209,985***0.0640.0590.066**0.058
(0.059)(0.063)(49,039)(52,741)(0.050)(0.053)(0.033)(0.037)
VT * Males−0.004−0.01418,04634,1850.0270.0540.0570.118
(0.073)(0.148)(68,758)(140,051)(0.062)(0.127)(0.045)(0.093)
VT program0.104**0.218**82,763***176,738***0.094**0.201***0.046*0.102**
(0.042)(0.087)(31,592)(66,497)(0.037)(0.076)(0.024)(0.051)
Age 15–210.0070.022−26,901−20,498−0.0020.004−0.017−0.017
(0.062)(0.067)(43,369)(112,393)(0.049)(0.054)(0.029)(0.032)
VT * age 15 –21−0.143**−0.293**−83,909−20,498−0.099*−0.196*−0.028−0.050
(0.072)(0.148)(54,541)(47,534)(0.058)(0.119)(0.038)(0.078)
VT program0.096**0.211**61,903*138,853**0.082**0.182**0.054**0.121**
(0.040)(0.086)(32,936)(70,851)(0.034)(0.075)(0.024)(0.052)
Poor0.0730.112−30,004−15,8890.0040.0290.0040.023
(0.065)(0.074)(37,829)(45,280)(0.051)(0.059)(0.027)(0.033)
VT * poor−0.158**−0.397**−32,749−71,324−0.083−0.201−0.068*−0.167*
(0.079)(0.198)(54,680)(134,722)(0.063)(0.158)(0.035)(0.086)
VT Program0.202***0.386***116,158**227,330**0.130**0.255**0.0420.088
(0.063)(0.118)(54,105)(101,169)(0.057)(0.105)(0.034)(0.063)
Less than high school0.0560.0959322,7480.0150.0440.0050.004
(0.082)(0.098)(61,177)(75,358)(0.070)(0.082)(0.044)(0.053)
High school0.0160.032−17,922−15,594−0.049−0.049−0.021−0.024
(0.063)(0.069)(44,683)(48,544)(0.075)(0.059)(0.033)(0.035)
VT * less high school−0.274***−0.597**−157,077*−351,078−0.189**−0.439**−0.030−0.047
(0.098)(0.263)(87,597)(228,775)(0.083)(0.213)(0.053)(0.141)
VT * high school−0.174**−0.313**−57,243−94,337−0.055−0.0870.0010.009
(0.078)(0.143)(65,074)(119,056)(0.068)(0.124)(0.042)(0.077)
VT Program−0.065−0.160−17,368−37,2800.0490.1310.0170.049
(0.063)(0.154)(47,692)(116,469)(0.049)(0.122)(0.033)(0.082)
Optimism−0.064−0.0924,070−12,4010.0650.004−0.010−0.014
(0.062)(0.069)(50,163)(55,242)(0.051)(0.139)(0.032)(0.036)
VT * optimism0.177**0.386**103,921*216,632*0.0130.0640.0270.047
(0.075)(0.066)(56,070)(125,034)(0.063)(0.077)(0.040)(0.089)
N10431043104310431043104310431043
Employment 6-monthEarnings 6-monthSkills match 6-monthSelf-employment 6-month
ITTTOTITTTOTITTTOTITTTOT
VT Program(0.056)(0.132)(46,984)(110,833*)(0.048)(0.114)(0.016)(0.041)
(0.043)(0.096)(29,500)(65,876)(0.036)(0.079)(0.021)(0.047)
Males0.157***0.156**213,390***209,985***0.0640.0590.066**0.058
(0.059)(0.063)(49,039)(52,741)(0.050)(0.053)(0.033)(0.037)
VT * Males−0.004−0.01418,04634,1850.0270.0540.0570.118
(0.073)(0.148)(68,758)(140,051)(0.062)(0.127)(0.045)(0.093)
VT program0.104**0.218**82,763***176,738***0.094**0.201***0.046*0.102**
(0.042)(0.087)(31,592)(66,497)(0.037)(0.076)(0.024)(0.051)
Age 15–210.0070.022−26,901−20,498−0.0020.004−0.017−0.017
(0.062)(0.067)(43,369)(112,393)(0.049)(0.054)(0.029)(0.032)
VT * age 15 –21−0.143**−0.293**−83,909−20,498−0.099*−0.196*−0.028−0.050
(0.072)(0.148)(54,541)(47,534)(0.058)(0.119)(0.038)(0.078)
VT program0.096**0.211**61,903*138,853**0.082**0.182**0.054**0.121**
(0.040)(0.086)(32,936)(70,851)(0.034)(0.075)(0.024)(0.052)
Poor0.0730.112−30,004−15,8890.0040.0290.0040.023
(0.065)(0.074)(37,829)(45,280)(0.051)(0.059)(0.027)(0.033)
VT * poor−0.158**−0.397**−32,749−71,324−0.083−0.201−0.068*−0.167*
(0.079)(0.198)(54,680)(134,722)(0.063)(0.158)(0.035)(0.086)
VT Program0.202***0.386***116,158**227,330**0.130**0.255**0.0420.088
(0.063)(0.118)(54,105)(101,169)(0.057)(0.105)(0.034)(0.063)
Less than high school0.0560.0959322,7480.0150.0440.0050.004
(0.082)(0.098)(61,177)(75,358)(0.070)(0.082)(0.044)(0.053)
High school0.0160.032−17,922−15,594−0.049−0.049−0.021−0.024
(0.063)(0.069)(44,683)(48,544)(0.075)(0.059)(0.033)(0.035)
VT * less high school−0.274***−0.597**−157,077*−351,078−0.189**−0.439**−0.030−0.047
(0.098)(0.263)(87,597)(228,775)(0.083)(0.213)(0.053)(0.141)
VT * high school−0.174**−0.313**−57,243−94,337−0.055−0.0870.0010.009
(0.078)(0.143)(65,074)(119,056)(0.068)(0.124)(0.042)(0.077)
VT Program−0.065−0.160−17,368−37,2800.0490.1310.0170.049
(0.063)(0.154)(47,692)(116,469)(0.049)(0.122)(0.033)(0.082)
Optimism−0.064−0.0924,070−12,4010.0650.004−0.010−0.014
(0.062)(0.069)(50,163)(55,242)(0.051)(0.139)(0.032)(0.036)
VT * optimism0.177**0.386**103,921*216,632*0.0130.0640.0270.047
(0.075)(0.066)(56,070)(125,034)(0.063)(0.077)(0.040)(0.089)
N10431043104310431043104310431043

Source: Author's calculations based on First Follow up data.

Note: Robust standard errors in parentheses. ITT and TOT parameters estimated by multivariate OLS models with control variables selected by the post-double LASSO selection approach. See notes in table 4 for full specification details. Poor is defined as 1 for those in the bottom quantile of the household wealth assets index. Index is estimated by PCA and includes indicators for whether unit lives in a slum (Ger), has car, motorcycle, computer at home, washing machine, vacuum cleaner, TV, and refrigerator. ***p < 0.01, **p < 0.05, *p < 0.1.

Table 5a.

Heterogenous Impacts for VT Program, 6 months Mongolian VT Program, 2014–2016

Employment 6-monthEarnings 6-monthSkills match 6-monthSelf-employment 6-month
ITTTOTITTTOTITTTOTITTTOT
VT Program(0.056)(0.132)(46,984)(110,833*)(0.048)(0.114)(0.016)(0.041)
(0.043)(0.096)(29,500)(65,876)(0.036)(0.079)(0.021)(0.047)
Males0.157***0.156**213,390***209,985***0.0640.0590.066**0.058
(0.059)(0.063)(49,039)(52,741)(0.050)(0.053)(0.033)(0.037)
VT * Males−0.004−0.01418,04634,1850.0270.0540.0570.118
(0.073)(0.148)(68,758)(140,051)(0.062)(0.127)(0.045)(0.093)
VT program0.104**0.218**82,763***176,738***0.094**0.201***0.046*0.102**
(0.042)(0.087)(31,592)(66,497)(0.037)(0.076)(0.024)(0.051)
Age 15–210.0070.022−26,901−20,498−0.0020.004−0.017−0.017
(0.062)(0.067)(43,369)(112,393)(0.049)(0.054)(0.029)(0.032)
VT * age 15 –21−0.143**−0.293**−83,909−20,498−0.099*−0.196*−0.028−0.050
(0.072)(0.148)(54,541)(47,534)(0.058)(0.119)(0.038)(0.078)
VT program0.096**0.211**61,903*138,853**0.082**0.182**0.054**0.121**
(0.040)(0.086)(32,936)(70,851)(0.034)(0.075)(0.024)(0.052)
Poor0.0730.112−30,004−15,8890.0040.0290.0040.023
(0.065)(0.074)(37,829)(45,280)(0.051)(0.059)(0.027)(0.033)
VT * poor−0.158**−0.397**−32,749−71,324−0.083−0.201−0.068*−0.167*
(0.079)(0.198)(54,680)(134,722)(0.063)(0.158)(0.035)(0.086)
VT Program0.202***0.386***116,158**227,330**0.130**0.255**0.0420.088
(0.063)(0.118)(54,105)(101,169)(0.057)(0.105)(0.034)(0.063)
Less than high school0.0560.0959322,7480.0150.0440.0050.004
(0.082)(0.098)(61,177)(75,358)(0.070)(0.082)(0.044)(0.053)
High school0.0160.032−17,922−15,594−0.049−0.049−0.021−0.024
(0.063)(0.069)(44,683)(48,544)(0.075)(0.059)(0.033)(0.035)
VT * less high school−0.274***−0.597**−157,077*−351,078−0.189**−0.439**−0.030−0.047
(0.098)(0.263)(87,597)(228,775)(0.083)(0.213)(0.053)(0.141)
VT * high school−0.174**−0.313**−57,243−94,337−0.055−0.0870.0010.009
(0.078)(0.143)(65,074)(119,056)(0.068)(0.124)(0.042)(0.077)
VT Program−0.065−0.160−17,368−37,2800.0490.1310.0170.049
(0.063)(0.154)(47,692)(116,469)(0.049)(0.122)(0.033)(0.082)
Optimism−0.064−0.0924,070−12,4010.0650.004−0.010−0.014
(0.062)(0.069)(50,163)(55,242)(0.051)(0.139)(0.032)(0.036)
VT * optimism0.177**0.386**103,921*216,632*0.0130.0640.0270.047
(0.075)(0.066)(56,070)(125,034)(0.063)(0.077)(0.040)(0.089)
N10431043104310431043104310431043
Employment 6-monthEarnings 6-monthSkills match 6-monthSelf-employment 6-month
ITTTOTITTTOTITTTOTITTTOT
VT Program(0.056)(0.132)(46,984)(110,833*)(0.048)(0.114)(0.016)(0.041)
(0.043)(0.096)(29,500)(65,876)(0.036)(0.079)(0.021)(0.047)
Males0.157***0.156**213,390***209,985***0.0640.0590.066**0.058
(0.059)(0.063)(49,039)(52,741)(0.050)(0.053)(0.033)(0.037)
VT * Males−0.004−0.01418,04634,1850.0270.0540.0570.118
(0.073)(0.148)(68,758)(140,051)(0.062)(0.127)(0.045)(0.093)
VT program0.104**0.218**82,763***176,738***0.094**0.201***0.046*0.102**
(0.042)(0.087)(31,592)(66,497)(0.037)(0.076)(0.024)(0.051)
Age 15–210.0070.022−26,901−20,498−0.0020.004−0.017−0.017
(0.062)(0.067)(43,369)(112,393)(0.049)(0.054)(0.029)(0.032)
VT * age 15 –21−0.143**−0.293**−83,909−20,498−0.099*−0.196*−0.028−0.050
(0.072)(0.148)(54,541)(47,534)(0.058)(0.119)(0.038)(0.078)
VT program0.096**0.211**61,903*138,853**0.082**0.182**0.054**0.121**
(0.040)(0.086)(32,936)(70,851)(0.034)(0.075)(0.024)(0.052)
Poor0.0730.112−30,004−15,8890.0040.0290.0040.023
(0.065)(0.074)(37,829)(45,280)(0.051)(0.059)(0.027)(0.033)
VT * poor−0.158**−0.397**−32,749−71,324−0.083−0.201−0.068*−0.167*
(0.079)(0.198)(54,680)(134,722)(0.063)(0.158)(0.035)(0.086)
VT Program0.202***0.386***116,158**227,330**0.130**0.255**0.0420.088
(0.063)(0.118)(54,105)(101,169)(0.057)(0.105)(0.034)(0.063)
Less than high school0.0560.0959322,7480.0150.0440.0050.004
(0.082)(0.098)(61,177)(75,358)(0.070)(0.082)(0.044)(0.053)
High school0.0160.032−17,922−15,594−0.049−0.049−0.021−0.024
(0.063)(0.069)(44,683)(48,544)(0.075)(0.059)(0.033)(0.035)
VT * less high school−0.274***−0.597**−157,077*−351,078−0.189**−0.439**−0.030−0.047
(0.098)(0.263)(87,597)(228,775)(0.083)(0.213)(0.053)(0.141)
VT * high school−0.174**−0.313**−57,243−94,337−0.055−0.0870.0010.009
(0.078)(0.143)(65,074)(119,056)(0.068)(0.124)(0.042)(0.077)
VT Program−0.065−0.160−17,368−37,2800.0490.1310.0170.049
(0.063)(0.154)(47,692)(116,469)(0.049)(0.122)(0.033)(0.082)
Optimism−0.064−0.0924,070−12,4010.0650.004−0.010−0.014
(0.062)(0.069)(50,163)(55,242)(0.051)(0.139)(0.032)(0.036)
VT * optimism0.177**0.386**103,921*216,632*0.0130.0640.0270.047
(0.075)(0.066)(56,070)(125,034)(0.063)(0.077)(0.040)(0.089)
N10431043104310431043104310431043

Source: Author's calculations based on First Follow up data.

Note: Robust standard errors in parentheses. ITT and TOT parameters estimated by multivariate OLS models with control variables selected by the post-double LASSO selection approach. See notes in table 4 for full specification details. Poor is defined as 1 for those in the bottom quantile of the household wealth assets index. Index is estimated by PCA and includes indicators for whether unit lives in a slum (Ger), has car, motorcycle, computer at home, washing machine, vacuum cleaner, TV, and refrigerator. ***p < 0.01, **p < 0.05, *p < 0.1.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close