Characteristic . | EOG . | VNG . | SCR . |
---|---|---|---|
Recording device | Ag/AgCl electrodes | Video camera | Copper coil embedded in silicon ring |
Principle | Corneo-retinal dipole potential | Image processing | Voltage changes induced in coil of wire moving in oscillating magnetic field |
Recording of horizontal eye movement | Good | Very good | Excellent |
Recording of vertical eye movement | Unacceptable | Very good | Excellent |
Recording of torsional eye movement | Not possible | 2D—not possible3D—Good | Excellent |
Approximate accuracy | 1-2° | 1° | 0.02° |
Head movement artefact | High | Low | Nil |
Sampling rate | >150Hz | Most clinical systems: 50 Hz Research systems: 200 Hz | 1000 Hz |
Amplifier drift | Yes | No | No |
Calibration | Repeatedly | Once | Once |
Errors due to: Blinks Changes inroom lighting Myogenic activity | Yes Yes Yes | Yes No No | No No No |
Patient tolerance | > 1 hour | 30–45 minutes | >30 minutes |
Value | Simple, inexpensive, readily available, clinical tool | More expensive, 2D recording relatively simple, good clinical tool except for saccades | Excellent research technique, too invasive for routine clinical use |
Characteristic . | EOG . | VNG . | SCR . |
---|---|---|---|
Recording device | Ag/AgCl electrodes | Video camera | Copper coil embedded in silicon ring |
Principle | Corneo-retinal dipole potential | Image processing | Voltage changes induced in coil of wire moving in oscillating magnetic field |
Recording of horizontal eye movement | Good | Very good | Excellent |
Recording of vertical eye movement | Unacceptable | Very good | Excellent |
Recording of torsional eye movement | Not possible | 2D—not possible3D—Good | Excellent |
Approximate accuracy | 1-2° | 1° | 0.02° |
Head movement artefact | High | Low | Nil |
Sampling rate | >150Hz | Most clinical systems: 50 Hz Research systems: 200 Hz | 1000 Hz |
Amplifier drift | Yes | No | No |
Calibration | Repeatedly | Once | Once |
Errors due to: Blinks Changes inroom lighting Myogenic activity | Yes Yes Yes | Yes No No | No No No |
Patient tolerance | > 1 hour | 30–45 minutes | >30 minutes |
Value | Simple, inexpensive, readily available, clinical tool | More expensive, 2D recording relatively simple, good clinical tool except for saccades | Excellent research technique, too invasive for routine clinical use |
This PDF is available to Subscribers Only
View Article Abstract & Purchase OptionsFor full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.