Table 1:

Clinical characteristics

VariableOverall N = 1310DH (≤20°C) N = 224LMH (20.1–24°C) N = 505HMH (24.1–28°C) N = 433MH (>28°C) N = 148P value*
Baseline characteristics
 Age (years), mean (SD)46.67 (10.34)47.75 (9.40)46.09 (11.13)46.84 (10.22)46.49 (10.34)0.217
 Body mass index (kg/m2), mean (SD)26.03 (4.57)25.66 (5.26)25.60 (4.26)26.41 (4.66)b27.10 (3.92)a,b<0.001
 Male sex, n (%)1026 (78.3)159 (71.0)398 (78.8)338 (78.1)131 (88.5)a,b,c0.001
 Time interval between onset and admission (days), median [IQR]2.00 [0.83, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 12.00]1.00 [0.46, 5.00]a,b0.79 [0.33, 4.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Acute, n (%)1096 (83.7)201 (89.7)391 (77.4)a370 (85.5)b134 (90.5)b<0.001
 Chest pain, n (%)1101 (84.0)201 (89.7)415 (82.2)370 (85.5)115 (77.7)a0.007
 Marfan syndrome, n (%)137 (10.5)22 (9.8)76 (15.0)32 (7.4)b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Smoking, n (%)567 (43.3)87 (38.8)206 (40.8)188 (43.4)86 (58.1)a,b,c0.001
 Alcohol addiction, n (%)134 (10.2)19 (8.5)37 (7.3)46 (10.6)32 (21.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Diabetes mellitus, n (%)36 (2.7)5 (2.2)10 (2.0)17 (3.9)4 (2.7)0.326
 Hypertension, n (%)1026 (78.3)163 (72.8)367 (72.7)359 (82.9)a,b137 (92.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Hyperlipaemia, n (%)181 (13.8)21 (9.4)77 (15.2)a70 (16.2)a13 (8.8)0.019
 Coronary artery disease, n (%)37 (2.8)7 (3.1)12 (2.4)11 (2.5)7 (4.7)0.451
 NYHA ≥3, n (%)48 (3.7)3 (1.3)6 (1.2)32 (7.4)a,b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Chronic kidney disease, n (%)47 (3.6)9 (4.0)23 (4.6)13 (3.0)2 (1.4)0.260
 COPD, n (%)9 (0.7)2 (0.9)3 (0.6)3 (0.7)1 (0.7)0.961
 Cerebrovascular disease, n (%)32 (2.4)9 (4.0)14 (2.8)6 (1.4)3 (2.0)0.188
 Family history of aortic disease, n (%)26 (2.0)4 (1.8)18 (3.6)3 (0.7)b1 (0.7)0.010
 History of cardiovascular surgery, n (%)60 (4.6)11 (4.9)28 (5.5)18 (4.2)3 (2.0)0.319
 History of TEVAR, n (%)33 (2.5)1 (0.4)14 (2.8)10 (2.3)8 (5.4)a0.023
 History of PCI, n (%)8 (0.6)2 (0.9)2 (0.4)4 (0.9)0 (0.0)0.612
 Preoperative lowest ejection fraction (%), mean (SD)59.96 (5.30)59.75 (5.68)59.67 (5.60)60.15 (4.94)60.68 (4.60)0.120
 Aortic insufficiency, n (%)d512 (39.1)88 (39.3)215 (42.6)165 (38.1)44 (29.7)b0.041
 Pericardial effusion, n (%)e51 (3.9)3 (1.3)20 (4.0)20 (4.6)8 (5.4)0.099
 Preoperative highest WBC (×109/l), median [IQR]10.98 [8.36, 13.80]10.81 [8.37, 13.83]10.68 [7.79, 13.33]11.22 [8.55, 14.00]12.00 [9.96, 14.74]a,b<0.001
 Preoperative lowest platelet (×109/l), median [IQR]176.00 [141.00, 222.00]167.00 [129.00, 211.00]174.00 [142.00, 220.00]182.00 [141.00, 225.00]183.00 [151.00, 227.25]a0.016
 Preoperative lowest haemoglobin (g/l), mean (SD)133.39 (19.35)129.31 (19.07)131.76 (21.10)135.23 (17.20)a,b139.75 (17.37)a,b<0.001
 TEM-E, n (%)<0.001
  TEM-E075 (5.7)12 (5.4)34 (6.7)19 (4.4)10 (6.8)
  TEM-E1782 (59.7)171 (76.3)356 (70.5)203 (46.9)a,b52 (35.1)a,b
  TEM-E2394 (30.1)40 (17.9)104 (20.6)182 (42.0)a,b68 (45.9)a,b
  TEM-E359 (4.5)1 (0.4)11 (2.2)29 (6.7)a,b18 (12.2)a,b
 TEM-M0, n (%)218 (16.6)34 (15.2)91 (18.0)68 (15.7)25 (16.9)0.734
 TEM-M1, n (%)248 (18.9)50 (22.3)92 (18.2)83 (19.2)23 (15.5)0.395
 TEM-M2, n (%)823 (62.8)171 (76.3)344 (68.1)242 (55.9)a,b66 (44.6)a,b<0.001
 TEM-M3, n (%)572 (43.7)79 (35.3)215 (42.6)204 (47.1)a74 (50.0)a0.011
Operative conditions
 Emergency, n (%)932 (71.1)150 (67.0)323 (64.0)337 (77.8)a,b122 (82.4)a,b<0.001
 Root surgery, n (%)<0.001
  Root sparing913 (69.7)139 (62.1)339 (67.1)309 (71.4)126 (85.1)a,b,c
  Bentall357 (27.3)77 (34.4)159 (31.5)104 (24.0)a17 (11.5)a,b,c
  Wheat34 (2.6)7 (3.1)7 (1.4)15 (3.5)5 (3.4)
  David6 (0.5)1 (0.4)0 (0.0)5 (1.2)0 (0.0)
 Coronary artery bypass graft, n (%)162 (12.4)42 (18.8)55 (10.9)a48 (11.1)a17 (11.5)0.024
 Mitral valve surgery, n (%)18 (1.4)3 (1.3)8 (1.6)7 (1.6)0 (0.0)0.531
 Aorta-femoral artery bypass, n (%)84 (6.4)8 (3.6)36 (7.1)34 (7.9)6 (4.1)0.096
 Frozen elephant trunk, n (%)1289 (98.4)223 (99.6)498 (98.6)422 (97.5)146 (98.6)0.233
 Operative time (hours), median [IQR]6.50 [5.50, 7.67]7.31 [6.33, 8.50]6.53 [5.67, 7.70]a6.25 [5.20, 7.42]a,b5.75 [4.92, 6.43]a,b,c<0.001
 CPB time (min), median [IQR]179.00 [149.00, 215.00]215.00 [188.75, 254.00]183.00 [155.00, 217.00]a165.00 [139.00, 195.00]a,b146.50 [127.00, 173.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Cross-clamp time (min), median [IQR]100.00 [83.00, 119.00]112.00 [98.00, 137.00]98.00 [84.00, 112.00]a98.00 [80.00, 120.00]a90.00 [68.75, 114.00]a,c<0.001
 HCA time (min), median [IQR]20.00 [16.00, 24.00]24.00 [20.75, 29.00]21.00 [18.00, 25.00]a17.00 [14.00, 20.00]a,b14.00 [6.00, 17.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Blood loss (ml), median [IQR]720.00 [600.00, 1000.00]800.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]660.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]720.00 [600.00, 900.00]780.00 [600.00, 900.00]0.614
 Red blood cell transfusion (U), median [IQR]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 2.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]b,c0.001
 Plasma transfusion (ml), median [IQR]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]400.00 [0.00, 800.00]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]200.00 [0.00, 600.00]a0.00 [0.00, 600.00]a,b<0.001
 Platelets transfusion (U), median [IQR]1.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]a1.00 [1.00, 2.00]a,b1.00 [0.00, 1.00]a,b,c<0.001
VariableOverall N = 1310DH (≤20°C) N = 224LMH (20.1–24°C) N = 505HMH (24.1–28°C) N = 433MH (>28°C) N = 148P value*
Baseline characteristics
 Age (years), mean (SD)46.67 (10.34)47.75 (9.40)46.09 (11.13)46.84 (10.22)46.49 (10.34)0.217
 Body mass index (kg/m2), mean (SD)26.03 (4.57)25.66 (5.26)25.60 (4.26)26.41 (4.66)b27.10 (3.92)a,b<0.001
 Male sex, n (%)1026 (78.3)159 (71.0)398 (78.8)338 (78.1)131 (88.5)a,b,c0.001
 Time interval between onset and admission (days), median [IQR]2.00 [0.83, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 12.00]1.00 [0.46, 5.00]a,b0.79 [0.33, 4.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Acute, n (%)1096 (83.7)201 (89.7)391 (77.4)a370 (85.5)b134 (90.5)b<0.001
 Chest pain, n (%)1101 (84.0)201 (89.7)415 (82.2)370 (85.5)115 (77.7)a0.007
 Marfan syndrome, n (%)137 (10.5)22 (9.8)76 (15.0)32 (7.4)b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Smoking, n (%)567 (43.3)87 (38.8)206 (40.8)188 (43.4)86 (58.1)a,b,c0.001
 Alcohol addiction, n (%)134 (10.2)19 (8.5)37 (7.3)46 (10.6)32 (21.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Diabetes mellitus, n (%)36 (2.7)5 (2.2)10 (2.0)17 (3.9)4 (2.7)0.326
 Hypertension, n (%)1026 (78.3)163 (72.8)367 (72.7)359 (82.9)a,b137 (92.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Hyperlipaemia, n (%)181 (13.8)21 (9.4)77 (15.2)a70 (16.2)a13 (8.8)0.019
 Coronary artery disease, n (%)37 (2.8)7 (3.1)12 (2.4)11 (2.5)7 (4.7)0.451
 NYHA ≥3, n (%)48 (3.7)3 (1.3)6 (1.2)32 (7.4)a,b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Chronic kidney disease, n (%)47 (3.6)9 (4.0)23 (4.6)13 (3.0)2 (1.4)0.260
 COPD, n (%)9 (0.7)2 (0.9)3 (0.6)3 (0.7)1 (0.7)0.961
 Cerebrovascular disease, n (%)32 (2.4)9 (4.0)14 (2.8)6 (1.4)3 (2.0)0.188
 Family history of aortic disease, n (%)26 (2.0)4 (1.8)18 (3.6)3 (0.7)b1 (0.7)0.010
 History of cardiovascular surgery, n (%)60 (4.6)11 (4.9)28 (5.5)18 (4.2)3 (2.0)0.319
 History of TEVAR, n (%)33 (2.5)1 (0.4)14 (2.8)10 (2.3)8 (5.4)a0.023
 History of PCI, n (%)8 (0.6)2 (0.9)2 (0.4)4 (0.9)0 (0.0)0.612
 Preoperative lowest ejection fraction (%), mean (SD)59.96 (5.30)59.75 (5.68)59.67 (5.60)60.15 (4.94)60.68 (4.60)0.120
 Aortic insufficiency, n (%)d512 (39.1)88 (39.3)215 (42.6)165 (38.1)44 (29.7)b0.041
 Pericardial effusion, n (%)e51 (3.9)3 (1.3)20 (4.0)20 (4.6)8 (5.4)0.099
 Preoperative highest WBC (×109/l), median [IQR]10.98 [8.36, 13.80]10.81 [8.37, 13.83]10.68 [7.79, 13.33]11.22 [8.55, 14.00]12.00 [9.96, 14.74]a,b<0.001
 Preoperative lowest platelet (×109/l), median [IQR]176.00 [141.00, 222.00]167.00 [129.00, 211.00]174.00 [142.00, 220.00]182.00 [141.00, 225.00]183.00 [151.00, 227.25]a0.016
 Preoperative lowest haemoglobin (g/l), mean (SD)133.39 (19.35)129.31 (19.07)131.76 (21.10)135.23 (17.20)a,b139.75 (17.37)a,b<0.001
 TEM-E, n (%)<0.001
  TEM-E075 (5.7)12 (5.4)34 (6.7)19 (4.4)10 (6.8)
  TEM-E1782 (59.7)171 (76.3)356 (70.5)203 (46.9)a,b52 (35.1)a,b
  TEM-E2394 (30.1)40 (17.9)104 (20.6)182 (42.0)a,b68 (45.9)a,b
  TEM-E359 (4.5)1 (0.4)11 (2.2)29 (6.7)a,b18 (12.2)a,b
 TEM-M0, n (%)218 (16.6)34 (15.2)91 (18.0)68 (15.7)25 (16.9)0.734
 TEM-M1, n (%)248 (18.9)50 (22.3)92 (18.2)83 (19.2)23 (15.5)0.395
 TEM-M2, n (%)823 (62.8)171 (76.3)344 (68.1)242 (55.9)a,b66 (44.6)a,b<0.001
 TEM-M3, n (%)572 (43.7)79 (35.3)215 (42.6)204 (47.1)a74 (50.0)a0.011
Operative conditions
 Emergency, n (%)932 (71.1)150 (67.0)323 (64.0)337 (77.8)a,b122 (82.4)a,b<0.001
 Root surgery, n (%)<0.001
  Root sparing913 (69.7)139 (62.1)339 (67.1)309 (71.4)126 (85.1)a,b,c
  Bentall357 (27.3)77 (34.4)159 (31.5)104 (24.0)a17 (11.5)a,b,c
  Wheat34 (2.6)7 (3.1)7 (1.4)15 (3.5)5 (3.4)
  David6 (0.5)1 (0.4)0 (0.0)5 (1.2)0 (0.0)
 Coronary artery bypass graft, n (%)162 (12.4)42 (18.8)55 (10.9)a48 (11.1)a17 (11.5)0.024
 Mitral valve surgery, n (%)18 (1.4)3 (1.3)8 (1.6)7 (1.6)0 (0.0)0.531
 Aorta-femoral artery bypass, n (%)84 (6.4)8 (3.6)36 (7.1)34 (7.9)6 (4.1)0.096
 Frozen elephant trunk, n (%)1289 (98.4)223 (99.6)498 (98.6)422 (97.5)146 (98.6)0.233
 Operative time (hours), median [IQR]6.50 [5.50, 7.67]7.31 [6.33, 8.50]6.53 [5.67, 7.70]a6.25 [5.20, 7.42]a,b5.75 [4.92, 6.43]a,b,c<0.001
 CPB time (min), median [IQR]179.00 [149.00, 215.00]215.00 [188.75, 254.00]183.00 [155.00, 217.00]a165.00 [139.00, 195.00]a,b146.50 [127.00, 173.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Cross-clamp time (min), median [IQR]100.00 [83.00, 119.00]112.00 [98.00, 137.00]98.00 [84.00, 112.00]a98.00 [80.00, 120.00]a90.00 [68.75, 114.00]a,c<0.001
 HCA time (min), median [IQR]20.00 [16.00, 24.00]24.00 [20.75, 29.00]21.00 [18.00, 25.00]a17.00 [14.00, 20.00]a,b14.00 [6.00, 17.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Blood loss (ml), median [IQR]720.00 [600.00, 1000.00]800.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]660.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]720.00 [600.00, 900.00]780.00 [600.00, 900.00]0.614
 Red blood cell transfusion (U), median [IQR]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 2.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]b,c0.001
 Plasma transfusion (ml), median [IQR]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]400.00 [0.00, 800.00]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]200.00 [0.00, 600.00]a0.00 [0.00, 600.00]a,b<0.001
 Platelets transfusion (U), median [IQR]1.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]a1.00 [1.00, 2.00]a,b1.00 [0.00, 1.00]a,b,c<0.001
*

P values accounted for the comparison of differences between 4 groups.

a

Compared with DH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

b

Compared with LMH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

c

Compared with HMH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

d

Patients with moderate or severe aortic insufficiency were included.

e

Patients with moderate or severe pericardial effusion were included.

COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; CPB: cardiopulmonary bypass; DH: deep hypothermia; HCA: hypothermia circulatory arrest; HMH: high-moderate hypothermia; IQR: interquartile range; LMH: low-moderate hypothermia; MH: mild hypothermia; NYHA: New York Heart Association; PCI: percutaneous coronary intervention; SD: standard deviation; TEM: type, entry, malperfusion; TEVAR: thoracic endovascular aortic repair; WBC: white blood cell.

Table 1:

Clinical characteristics

VariableOverall N = 1310DH (≤20°C) N = 224LMH (20.1–24°C) N = 505HMH (24.1–28°C) N = 433MH (>28°C) N = 148P value*
Baseline characteristics
 Age (years), mean (SD)46.67 (10.34)47.75 (9.40)46.09 (11.13)46.84 (10.22)46.49 (10.34)0.217
 Body mass index (kg/m2), mean (SD)26.03 (4.57)25.66 (5.26)25.60 (4.26)26.41 (4.66)b27.10 (3.92)a,b<0.001
 Male sex, n (%)1026 (78.3)159 (71.0)398 (78.8)338 (78.1)131 (88.5)a,b,c0.001
 Time interval between onset and admission (days), median [IQR]2.00 [0.83, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 12.00]1.00 [0.46, 5.00]a,b0.79 [0.33, 4.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Acute, n (%)1096 (83.7)201 (89.7)391 (77.4)a370 (85.5)b134 (90.5)b<0.001
 Chest pain, n (%)1101 (84.0)201 (89.7)415 (82.2)370 (85.5)115 (77.7)a0.007
 Marfan syndrome, n (%)137 (10.5)22 (9.8)76 (15.0)32 (7.4)b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Smoking, n (%)567 (43.3)87 (38.8)206 (40.8)188 (43.4)86 (58.1)a,b,c0.001
 Alcohol addiction, n (%)134 (10.2)19 (8.5)37 (7.3)46 (10.6)32 (21.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Diabetes mellitus, n (%)36 (2.7)5 (2.2)10 (2.0)17 (3.9)4 (2.7)0.326
 Hypertension, n (%)1026 (78.3)163 (72.8)367 (72.7)359 (82.9)a,b137 (92.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Hyperlipaemia, n (%)181 (13.8)21 (9.4)77 (15.2)a70 (16.2)a13 (8.8)0.019
 Coronary artery disease, n (%)37 (2.8)7 (3.1)12 (2.4)11 (2.5)7 (4.7)0.451
 NYHA ≥3, n (%)48 (3.7)3 (1.3)6 (1.2)32 (7.4)a,b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Chronic kidney disease, n (%)47 (3.6)9 (4.0)23 (4.6)13 (3.0)2 (1.4)0.260
 COPD, n (%)9 (0.7)2 (0.9)3 (0.6)3 (0.7)1 (0.7)0.961
 Cerebrovascular disease, n (%)32 (2.4)9 (4.0)14 (2.8)6 (1.4)3 (2.0)0.188
 Family history of aortic disease, n (%)26 (2.0)4 (1.8)18 (3.6)3 (0.7)b1 (0.7)0.010
 History of cardiovascular surgery, n (%)60 (4.6)11 (4.9)28 (5.5)18 (4.2)3 (2.0)0.319
 History of TEVAR, n (%)33 (2.5)1 (0.4)14 (2.8)10 (2.3)8 (5.4)a0.023
 History of PCI, n (%)8 (0.6)2 (0.9)2 (0.4)4 (0.9)0 (0.0)0.612
 Preoperative lowest ejection fraction (%), mean (SD)59.96 (5.30)59.75 (5.68)59.67 (5.60)60.15 (4.94)60.68 (4.60)0.120
 Aortic insufficiency, n (%)d512 (39.1)88 (39.3)215 (42.6)165 (38.1)44 (29.7)b0.041
 Pericardial effusion, n (%)e51 (3.9)3 (1.3)20 (4.0)20 (4.6)8 (5.4)0.099
 Preoperative highest WBC (×109/l), median [IQR]10.98 [8.36, 13.80]10.81 [8.37, 13.83]10.68 [7.79, 13.33]11.22 [8.55, 14.00]12.00 [9.96, 14.74]a,b<0.001
 Preoperative lowest platelet (×109/l), median [IQR]176.00 [141.00, 222.00]167.00 [129.00, 211.00]174.00 [142.00, 220.00]182.00 [141.00, 225.00]183.00 [151.00, 227.25]a0.016
 Preoperative lowest haemoglobin (g/l), mean (SD)133.39 (19.35)129.31 (19.07)131.76 (21.10)135.23 (17.20)a,b139.75 (17.37)a,b<0.001
 TEM-E, n (%)<0.001
  TEM-E075 (5.7)12 (5.4)34 (6.7)19 (4.4)10 (6.8)
  TEM-E1782 (59.7)171 (76.3)356 (70.5)203 (46.9)a,b52 (35.1)a,b
  TEM-E2394 (30.1)40 (17.9)104 (20.6)182 (42.0)a,b68 (45.9)a,b
  TEM-E359 (4.5)1 (0.4)11 (2.2)29 (6.7)a,b18 (12.2)a,b
 TEM-M0, n (%)218 (16.6)34 (15.2)91 (18.0)68 (15.7)25 (16.9)0.734
 TEM-M1, n (%)248 (18.9)50 (22.3)92 (18.2)83 (19.2)23 (15.5)0.395
 TEM-M2, n (%)823 (62.8)171 (76.3)344 (68.1)242 (55.9)a,b66 (44.6)a,b<0.001
 TEM-M3, n (%)572 (43.7)79 (35.3)215 (42.6)204 (47.1)a74 (50.0)a0.011
Operative conditions
 Emergency, n (%)932 (71.1)150 (67.0)323 (64.0)337 (77.8)a,b122 (82.4)a,b<0.001
 Root surgery, n (%)<0.001
  Root sparing913 (69.7)139 (62.1)339 (67.1)309 (71.4)126 (85.1)a,b,c
  Bentall357 (27.3)77 (34.4)159 (31.5)104 (24.0)a17 (11.5)a,b,c
  Wheat34 (2.6)7 (3.1)7 (1.4)15 (3.5)5 (3.4)
  David6 (0.5)1 (0.4)0 (0.0)5 (1.2)0 (0.0)
 Coronary artery bypass graft, n (%)162 (12.4)42 (18.8)55 (10.9)a48 (11.1)a17 (11.5)0.024
 Mitral valve surgery, n (%)18 (1.4)3 (1.3)8 (1.6)7 (1.6)0 (0.0)0.531
 Aorta-femoral artery bypass, n (%)84 (6.4)8 (3.6)36 (7.1)34 (7.9)6 (4.1)0.096
 Frozen elephant trunk, n (%)1289 (98.4)223 (99.6)498 (98.6)422 (97.5)146 (98.6)0.233
 Operative time (hours), median [IQR]6.50 [5.50, 7.67]7.31 [6.33, 8.50]6.53 [5.67, 7.70]a6.25 [5.20, 7.42]a,b5.75 [4.92, 6.43]a,b,c<0.001
 CPB time (min), median [IQR]179.00 [149.00, 215.00]215.00 [188.75, 254.00]183.00 [155.00, 217.00]a165.00 [139.00, 195.00]a,b146.50 [127.00, 173.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Cross-clamp time (min), median [IQR]100.00 [83.00, 119.00]112.00 [98.00, 137.00]98.00 [84.00, 112.00]a98.00 [80.00, 120.00]a90.00 [68.75, 114.00]a,c<0.001
 HCA time (min), median [IQR]20.00 [16.00, 24.00]24.00 [20.75, 29.00]21.00 [18.00, 25.00]a17.00 [14.00, 20.00]a,b14.00 [6.00, 17.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Blood loss (ml), median [IQR]720.00 [600.00, 1000.00]800.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]660.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]720.00 [600.00, 900.00]780.00 [600.00, 900.00]0.614
 Red blood cell transfusion (U), median [IQR]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 2.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]b,c0.001
 Plasma transfusion (ml), median [IQR]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]400.00 [0.00, 800.00]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]200.00 [0.00, 600.00]a0.00 [0.00, 600.00]a,b<0.001
 Platelets transfusion (U), median [IQR]1.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]a1.00 [1.00, 2.00]a,b1.00 [0.00, 1.00]a,b,c<0.001
VariableOverall N = 1310DH (≤20°C) N = 224LMH (20.1–24°C) N = 505HMH (24.1–28°C) N = 433MH (>28°C) N = 148P value*
Baseline characteristics
 Age (years), mean (SD)46.67 (10.34)47.75 (9.40)46.09 (11.13)46.84 (10.22)46.49 (10.34)0.217
 Body mass index (kg/m2), mean (SD)26.03 (4.57)25.66 (5.26)25.60 (4.26)26.41 (4.66)b27.10 (3.92)a,b<0.001
 Male sex, n (%)1026 (78.3)159 (71.0)398 (78.8)338 (78.1)131 (88.5)a,b,c0.001
 Time interval between onset and admission (days), median [IQR]2.00 [0.83, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 7.00]3.00 [1.00, 12.00]1.00 [0.46, 5.00]a,b0.79 [0.33, 4.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Acute, n (%)1096 (83.7)201 (89.7)391 (77.4)a370 (85.5)b134 (90.5)b<0.001
 Chest pain, n (%)1101 (84.0)201 (89.7)415 (82.2)370 (85.5)115 (77.7)a0.007
 Marfan syndrome, n (%)137 (10.5)22 (9.8)76 (15.0)32 (7.4)b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Smoking, n (%)567 (43.3)87 (38.8)206 (40.8)188 (43.4)86 (58.1)a,b,c0.001
 Alcohol addiction, n (%)134 (10.2)19 (8.5)37 (7.3)46 (10.6)32 (21.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Diabetes mellitus, n (%)36 (2.7)5 (2.2)10 (2.0)17 (3.9)4 (2.7)0.326
 Hypertension, n (%)1026 (78.3)163 (72.8)367 (72.7)359 (82.9)a,b137 (92.6)a,b,c<0.001
 Hyperlipaemia, n (%)181 (13.8)21 (9.4)77 (15.2)a70 (16.2)a13 (8.8)0.019
 Coronary artery disease, n (%)37 (2.8)7 (3.1)12 (2.4)11 (2.5)7 (4.7)0.451
 NYHA ≥3, n (%)48 (3.7)3 (1.3)6 (1.2)32 (7.4)a,b7 (4.7)b<0.001
 Chronic kidney disease, n (%)47 (3.6)9 (4.0)23 (4.6)13 (3.0)2 (1.4)0.260
 COPD, n (%)9 (0.7)2 (0.9)3 (0.6)3 (0.7)1 (0.7)0.961
 Cerebrovascular disease, n (%)32 (2.4)9 (4.0)14 (2.8)6 (1.4)3 (2.0)0.188
 Family history of aortic disease, n (%)26 (2.0)4 (1.8)18 (3.6)3 (0.7)b1 (0.7)0.010
 History of cardiovascular surgery, n (%)60 (4.6)11 (4.9)28 (5.5)18 (4.2)3 (2.0)0.319
 History of TEVAR, n (%)33 (2.5)1 (0.4)14 (2.8)10 (2.3)8 (5.4)a0.023
 History of PCI, n (%)8 (0.6)2 (0.9)2 (0.4)4 (0.9)0 (0.0)0.612
 Preoperative lowest ejection fraction (%), mean (SD)59.96 (5.30)59.75 (5.68)59.67 (5.60)60.15 (4.94)60.68 (4.60)0.120
 Aortic insufficiency, n (%)d512 (39.1)88 (39.3)215 (42.6)165 (38.1)44 (29.7)b0.041
 Pericardial effusion, n (%)e51 (3.9)3 (1.3)20 (4.0)20 (4.6)8 (5.4)0.099
 Preoperative highest WBC (×109/l), median [IQR]10.98 [8.36, 13.80]10.81 [8.37, 13.83]10.68 [7.79, 13.33]11.22 [8.55, 14.00]12.00 [9.96, 14.74]a,b<0.001
 Preoperative lowest platelet (×109/l), median [IQR]176.00 [141.00, 222.00]167.00 [129.00, 211.00]174.00 [142.00, 220.00]182.00 [141.00, 225.00]183.00 [151.00, 227.25]a0.016
 Preoperative lowest haemoglobin (g/l), mean (SD)133.39 (19.35)129.31 (19.07)131.76 (21.10)135.23 (17.20)a,b139.75 (17.37)a,b<0.001
 TEM-E, n (%)<0.001
  TEM-E075 (5.7)12 (5.4)34 (6.7)19 (4.4)10 (6.8)
  TEM-E1782 (59.7)171 (76.3)356 (70.5)203 (46.9)a,b52 (35.1)a,b
  TEM-E2394 (30.1)40 (17.9)104 (20.6)182 (42.0)a,b68 (45.9)a,b
  TEM-E359 (4.5)1 (0.4)11 (2.2)29 (6.7)a,b18 (12.2)a,b
 TEM-M0, n (%)218 (16.6)34 (15.2)91 (18.0)68 (15.7)25 (16.9)0.734
 TEM-M1, n (%)248 (18.9)50 (22.3)92 (18.2)83 (19.2)23 (15.5)0.395
 TEM-M2, n (%)823 (62.8)171 (76.3)344 (68.1)242 (55.9)a,b66 (44.6)a,b<0.001
 TEM-M3, n (%)572 (43.7)79 (35.3)215 (42.6)204 (47.1)a74 (50.0)a0.011
Operative conditions
 Emergency, n (%)932 (71.1)150 (67.0)323 (64.0)337 (77.8)a,b122 (82.4)a,b<0.001
 Root surgery, n (%)<0.001
  Root sparing913 (69.7)139 (62.1)339 (67.1)309 (71.4)126 (85.1)a,b,c
  Bentall357 (27.3)77 (34.4)159 (31.5)104 (24.0)a17 (11.5)a,b,c
  Wheat34 (2.6)7 (3.1)7 (1.4)15 (3.5)5 (3.4)
  David6 (0.5)1 (0.4)0 (0.0)5 (1.2)0 (0.0)
 Coronary artery bypass graft, n (%)162 (12.4)42 (18.8)55 (10.9)a48 (11.1)a17 (11.5)0.024
 Mitral valve surgery, n (%)18 (1.4)3 (1.3)8 (1.6)7 (1.6)0 (0.0)0.531
 Aorta-femoral artery bypass, n (%)84 (6.4)8 (3.6)36 (7.1)34 (7.9)6 (4.1)0.096
 Frozen elephant trunk, n (%)1289 (98.4)223 (99.6)498 (98.6)422 (97.5)146 (98.6)0.233
 Operative time (hours), median [IQR]6.50 [5.50, 7.67]7.31 [6.33, 8.50]6.53 [5.67, 7.70]a6.25 [5.20, 7.42]a,b5.75 [4.92, 6.43]a,b,c<0.001
 CPB time (min), median [IQR]179.00 [149.00, 215.00]215.00 [188.75, 254.00]183.00 [155.00, 217.00]a165.00 [139.00, 195.00]a,b146.50 [127.00, 173.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Cross-clamp time (min), median [IQR]100.00 [83.00, 119.00]112.00 [98.00, 137.00]98.00 [84.00, 112.00]a98.00 [80.00, 120.00]a90.00 [68.75, 114.00]a,c<0.001
 HCA time (min), median [IQR]20.00 [16.00, 24.00]24.00 [20.75, 29.00]21.00 [18.00, 25.00]a17.00 [14.00, 20.00]a,b14.00 [6.00, 17.00]a,b,c<0.001
 Blood loss (ml), median [IQR]720.00 [600.00, 1000.00]800.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]660.00 [600.00, 1,200.00]720.00 [600.00, 900.00]780.00 [600.00, 900.00]0.614
 Red blood cell transfusion (U), median [IQR]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]0.00 [0.00, 2.00]0.00 [0.00, 0.00]b,c0.001
 Plasma transfusion (ml), median [IQR]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]400.00 [0.00, 800.00]400.00 [0.00, 600.00]200.00 [0.00, 600.00]a0.00 [0.00, 600.00]a,b<0.001
 Platelets transfusion (U), median [IQR]1.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]2.00 [1.00, 2.00]a1.00 [1.00, 2.00]a,b1.00 [0.00, 1.00]a,b,c<0.001
*

P values accounted for the comparison of differences between 4 groups.

a

Compared with DH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

b

Compared with LMH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

c

Compared with HMH group, adjusted P < 0.05.

d

Patients with moderate or severe aortic insufficiency were included.

e

Patients with moderate or severe pericardial effusion were included.

COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; CPB: cardiopulmonary bypass; DH: deep hypothermia; HCA: hypothermia circulatory arrest; HMH: high-moderate hypothermia; IQR: interquartile range; LMH: low-moderate hypothermia; MH: mild hypothermia; NYHA: New York Heart Association; PCI: percutaneous coronary intervention; SD: standard deviation; TEM: type, entry, malperfusion; TEVAR: thoracic endovascular aortic repair; WBC: white blood cell.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close