| Outcome (all procedures) . | Studies (cohorts) . | Patients . | Estimate (95% CI) . | I2% . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 12 (15) | 1442 | 62.3 (59.5-65.2) | 85.36 |
| Physical well-being | 10 (12) | 1229 | 79.7 (71.3-88.0) | 99.25 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 9 (10) | 896 | 67.2 (63.9-70.4) | 86.27 |
| Sexual well-being | 8 (9) | 777 | 58.5 (54.9-62.0) | 84.00 |
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 52 (70) | 9650 | 68.1 (65.5-70.8) | 99.40 |
| Physical well-being | 44 (58) | 5400 | 71.1 (67.8-74.4) | 99.10 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 44 (59) | 5269 | 76.2 (72.5-79.9) | 99.16 |
| Sexual well-being | 39 (53) | 4190 | 61.8 (59.6-64.1) | 94.10 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 14 (17) | 2042 | 80.2 (73.7-86.8) | 99.32 |
| Satisfaction with outcome | 11 (13) | 689 | 80.0 (73.3-86.8) | 94.45 |
| Satisfaction with nipple complex | 5 (6) | 369 | 85.0 (74.7-95.2) | 83.88 |
| Outcome (BCS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 26 (29) | 6751 | 62.9 (58.3-67.5) | 99.50 |
| Physical well-being | 24 (29) | 3374 | 71.9 (67.3-76.5) | 99.38 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 23 (28) | 3071 | 73.3 (68.4-78.1) | 99.24 |
| Sexual well-being | 20 (25) | 2316 | 56.4 (53.4-59.3) | 93.55 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (9) | 1085 | 80.8 (74.2-87.3) | 98.37 |
| Outcome (BCS + OBS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 30 (41) | 2899 | 72.0 (68.0-76.1) | 99.31 |
| Physical well-being | 22 (29) | 2026 | 70.3 (64.2-76.5 | 98.46 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 24 (31) | 2198 | 78.9 (71.5-86.4) | 99.05 |
| Sexual well-being | 21 (28) | 1874 | 66.6 (62.6-70.5) | 94.09 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (8) | 957 | 81.6 (69.0-94.3) | 99.55 |
| Normative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | NA | 1201 | 58.0 (0.5) | NA |
| Physical well-being | NA | 1201 | 93 (0.3) | NA |
| Psychosocial well-being | NA | 1201 | 71 (0.5) | NA |
| Sexual well-being | NA | 1201 | 56 (0.5) | NA |
| Outcome (all procedures) . | Studies (cohorts) . | Patients . | Estimate (95% CI) . | I2% . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 12 (15) | 1442 | 62.3 (59.5-65.2) | 85.36 |
| Physical well-being | 10 (12) | 1229 | 79.7 (71.3-88.0) | 99.25 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 9 (10) | 896 | 67.2 (63.9-70.4) | 86.27 |
| Sexual well-being | 8 (9) | 777 | 58.5 (54.9-62.0) | 84.00 |
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 52 (70) | 9650 | 68.1 (65.5-70.8) | 99.40 |
| Physical well-being | 44 (58) | 5400 | 71.1 (67.8-74.4) | 99.10 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 44 (59) | 5269 | 76.2 (72.5-79.9) | 99.16 |
| Sexual well-being | 39 (53) | 4190 | 61.8 (59.6-64.1) | 94.10 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 14 (17) | 2042 | 80.2 (73.7-86.8) | 99.32 |
| Satisfaction with outcome | 11 (13) | 689 | 80.0 (73.3-86.8) | 94.45 |
| Satisfaction with nipple complex | 5 (6) | 369 | 85.0 (74.7-95.2) | 83.88 |
| Outcome (BCS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 26 (29) | 6751 | 62.9 (58.3-67.5) | 99.50 |
| Physical well-being | 24 (29) | 3374 | 71.9 (67.3-76.5) | 99.38 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 23 (28) | 3071 | 73.3 (68.4-78.1) | 99.24 |
| Sexual well-being | 20 (25) | 2316 | 56.4 (53.4-59.3) | 93.55 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (9) | 1085 | 80.8 (74.2-87.3) | 98.37 |
| Outcome (BCS + OBS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 30 (41) | 2899 | 72.0 (68.0-76.1) | 99.31 |
| Physical well-being | 22 (29) | 2026 | 70.3 (64.2-76.5 | 98.46 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 24 (31) | 2198 | 78.9 (71.5-86.4) | 99.05 |
| Sexual well-being | 21 (28) | 1874 | 66.6 (62.6-70.5) | 94.09 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (8) | 957 | 81.6 (69.0-94.3) | 99.55 |
| Normative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | NA | 1201 | 58.0 (0.5) | NA |
| Physical well-being | NA | 1201 | 93 (0.3) | NA |
| Psychosocial well-being | NA | 1201 | 71 (0.5) | NA |
| Sexual well-being | NA | 1201 | 56 (0.5) | NA |
Results presented for the entire cohort and for the subgroups receiving BCS alone or BCS + OBS. All heterogeneity values are significant (P < .001). Normative data as provided by Mundy et al.13 BCS, breast-conserving surgery; CI, confidence interval; MA, meta-analysis; NA, not applicable; OBS, oncoplastic surgery.
| Outcome (all procedures) . | Studies (cohorts) . | Patients . | Estimate (95% CI) . | I2% . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 12 (15) | 1442 | 62.3 (59.5-65.2) | 85.36 |
| Physical well-being | 10 (12) | 1229 | 79.7 (71.3-88.0) | 99.25 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 9 (10) | 896 | 67.2 (63.9-70.4) | 86.27 |
| Sexual well-being | 8 (9) | 777 | 58.5 (54.9-62.0) | 84.00 |
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 52 (70) | 9650 | 68.1 (65.5-70.8) | 99.40 |
| Physical well-being | 44 (58) | 5400 | 71.1 (67.8-74.4) | 99.10 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 44 (59) | 5269 | 76.2 (72.5-79.9) | 99.16 |
| Sexual well-being | 39 (53) | 4190 | 61.8 (59.6-64.1) | 94.10 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 14 (17) | 2042 | 80.2 (73.7-86.8) | 99.32 |
| Satisfaction with outcome | 11 (13) | 689 | 80.0 (73.3-86.8) | 94.45 |
| Satisfaction with nipple complex | 5 (6) | 369 | 85.0 (74.7-95.2) | 83.88 |
| Outcome (BCS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 26 (29) | 6751 | 62.9 (58.3-67.5) | 99.50 |
| Physical well-being | 24 (29) | 3374 | 71.9 (67.3-76.5) | 99.38 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 23 (28) | 3071 | 73.3 (68.4-78.1) | 99.24 |
| Sexual well-being | 20 (25) | 2316 | 56.4 (53.4-59.3) | 93.55 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (9) | 1085 | 80.8 (74.2-87.3) | 98.37 |
| Outcome (BCS + OBS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 30 (41) | 2899 | 72.0 (68.0-76.1) | 99.31 |
| Physical well-being | 22 (29) | 2026 | 70.3 (64.2-76.5 | 98.46 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 24 (31) | 2198 | 78.9 (71.5-86.4) | 99.05 |
| Sexual well-being | 21 (28) | 1874 | 66.6 (62.6-70.5) | 94.09 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (8) | 957 | 81.6 (69.0-94.3) | 99.55 |
| Normative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | NA | 1201 | 58.0 (0.5) | NA |
| Physical well-being | NA | 1201 | 93 (0.3) | NA |
| Psychosocial well-being | NA | 1201 | 71 (0.5) | NA |
| Sexual well-being | NA | 1201 | 56 (0.5) | NA |
| Outcome (all procedures) . | Studies (cohorts) . | Patients . | Estimate (95% CI) . | I2% . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 12 (15) | 1442 | 62.3 (59.5-65.2) | 85.36 |
| Physical well-being | 10 (12) | 1229 | 79.7 (71.3-88.0) | 99.25 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 9 (10) | 896 | 67.2 (63.9-70.4) | 86.27 |
| Sexual well-being | 8 (9) | 777 | 58.5 (54.9-62.0) | 84.00 |
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 52 (70) | 9650 | 68.1 (65.5-70.8) | 99.40 |
| Physical well-being | 44 (58) | 5400 | 71.1 (67.8-74.4) | 99.10 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 44 (59) | 5269 | 76.2 (72.5-79.9) | 99.16 |
| Sexual well-being | 39 (53) | 4190 | 61.8 (59.6-64.1) | 94.10 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 14 (17) | 2042 | 80.2 (73.7-86.8) | 99.32 |
| Satisfaction with outcome | 11 (13) | 689 | 80.0 (73.3-86.8) | 94.45 |
| Satisfaction with nipple complex | 5 (6) | 369 | 85.0 (74.7-95.2) | 83.88 |
| Outcome (BCS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 26 (29) | 6751 | 62.9 (58.3-67.5) | 99.50 |
| Physical well-being | 24 (29) | 3374 | 71.9 (67.3-76.5) | 99.38 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 23 (28) | 3071 | 73.3 (68.4-78.1) | 99.24 |
| Sexual well-being | 20 (25) | 2316 | 56.4 (53.4-59.3) | 93.55 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (9) | 1085 | 80.8 (74.2-87.3) | 98.37 |
| Outcome (BCS + OBS) | ||||
| Postoperative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | 30 (41) | 2899 | 72.0 (68.0-76.1) | 99.31 |
| Physical well-being | 22 (29) | 2026 | 70.3 (64.2-76.5 | 98.46 |
| Psychosocial well-being | 24 (31) | 2198 | 78.9 (71.5-86.4) | 99.05 |
| Sexual well-being | 21 (28) | 1874 | 66.6 (62.6-70.5) | 94.09 |
| Postradiotherapy well-being | 7 (8) | 957 | 81.6 (69.0-94.3) | 99.55 |
| Normative | ||||
| Overall satisfaction with the breast | NA | 1201 | 58.0 (0.5) | NA |
| Physical well-being | NA | 1201 | 93 (0.3) | NA |
| Psychosocial well-being | NA | 1201 | 71 (0.5) | NA |
| Sexual well-being | NA | 1201 | 56 (0.5) | NA |
Results presented for the entire cohort and for the subgroups receiving BCS alone or BCS + OBS. All heterogeneity values are significant (P < .001). Normative data as provided by Mundy et al.13 BCS, breast-conserving surgery; CI, confidence interval; MA, meta-analysis; NA, not applicable; OBS, oncoplastic surgery.
This PDF is available to Subscribers Only
View Article Abstract & Purchase OptionsFor full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.
