Table 1. Open in new tab Areas of... | Oxford Academic

Table 1.

Open in new tab

Areas of revision (adapted from Khuder and Petrić (2022) .

Areas of revision	Example question(s)
Disciplinary conventions
Terminology check	Have I used the correct terminology throughout my paper?
Argument support	Are my arguments robustly supported with evidence from the literature and/or my results?
Research positioning	Is my research perspective clearly stated? Do I reference studies and argue from within the same field of research? Have I made the relevance of my research clear to an international audience?
Precision of information	Is the information I present accurate and precise?
Reader-awareness	Can my reader easily follow and understand my arguments? Are they likely to find them persuasive?
Writing conventions
Text organization	Is the structure of my text clear, facilitating comprehension at both detailed (micro) and overall (macro) levels?
Language and grammar	Is the language in my text clear and concise? Have I thoroughly checked for grammatical and lexical errors?
Publishing conventions
Journal guidelines compliance	Have I followed the journal’s author guidelines? Have I reviewed recent articles published in the journal to match their formatting style?

Areas of revision	Example question(s)
Disciplinary conventions
Terminology check	Have I used the correct terminology throughout my paper?
Argument support	Are my arguments robustly supported with evidence from the literature and/or my results?
Research positioning	Is my research perspective clearly stated? Do I reference studies and argue from within the same field of research? Have I made the relevance of my research clear to an international audience?
Precision of information	Is the information I present accurate and precise?
Reader-awareness	Can my reader easily follow and understand my arguments? Are they likely to find them persuasive?
Writing conventions
Text organization	Is the structure of my text clear, facilitating comprehension at both detailed (micro) and overall (macro) levels?
Language and grammar	Is the language in my text clear and concise? Have I thoroughly checked for grammatical and lexical errors?
Publishing conventions
Journal guidelines compliance	Have I followed the journal’s author guidelines? Have I reviewed recent articles published in the journal to match their formatting style?

Table 1.

Open in new tab

Areas of revision (adapted from Khuder and Petrić (2022) .

Areas of revision	Example question(s)
Disciplinary conventions
Terminology check	Have I used the correct terminology throughout my paper?
Argument support	Are my arguments robustly supported with evidence from the literature and/or my results?
Research positioning	Is my research perspective clearly stated? Do I reference studies and argue from within the same field of research? Have I made the relevance of my research clear to an international audience?
Precision of information	Is the information I present accurate and precise?
Reader-awareness	Can my reader easily follow and understand my arguments? Are they likely to find them persuasive?
Writing conventions
Text organization	Is the structure of my text clear, facilitating comprehension at both detailed (micro) and overall (macro) levels?
Language and grammar	Is the language in my text clear and concise? Have I thoroughly checked for grammatical and lexical errors?
Publishing conventions
Journal guidelines compliance	Have I followed the journal’s author guidelines? Have I reviewed recent articles published in the journal to match their formatting style?

Areas of revision	Example question(s)
Disciplinary conventions
Terminology check	Have I used the correct terminology throughout my paper?
Argument support	Are my arguments robustly supported with evidence from the literature and/or my results?
Research positioning	Is my research perspective clearly stated? Do I reference studies and argue from within the same field of research? Have I made the relevance of my research clear to an international audience?
Precision of information	Is the information I present accurate and precise?
Reader-awareness	Can my reader easily follow and understand my arguments? Are they likely to find them persuasive?
Writing conventions
Text organization	Is the structure of my text clear, facilitating comprehension at both detailed (micro) and overall (macro) levels?
Language and grammar	Is the language in my text clear and concise? Have I thoroughly checked for grammatical and lexical errors?
Publishing conventions
Journal guidelines compliance	Have I followed the journal’s author guidelines? Have I reviewed recent articles published in the journal to match their formatting style?