Selected insecticide treatments were evaluated for control of tarnished and clouded plant bugs in blooming cotton at the West Tennessee Research and Education Center (Jackson, TN). Cotton was planted on 5 May. The test was arranged in an RCB design with four replicates. Individual plots were 12.67 × 35 ft and planted at a rate of four seeds per row ft. Treatments were applied with a high-clearance sprayer calibrated to deliver 9.4 gpa at 40 psi with 8001 flat fan nozzles. The first application was made 22 Jul (Appl A) to cotton when plant bugs exceeded threshold. A second application was made (29 Jul, Appl B) as populations in all treatments exceeded the economic threshold of six plant bugs per 10 row feet. Plots were sampled with a standard 2.5 × 2.5 ft black cloth shake sheet by placing the sheet between two rows and vigorously shaking plants to dislodge insects. On each date, two shake sheet samples were taken on the center two rows (10 row ft total) of all plots. Plant bug control was evaluated 28 Jul, 6 days after initial treatment (Appl A, 6 DATA); and 4 Aug, 6 days after the second treatment (Appl B, 6 DATB). Yield was taken 8 Oct by harvesting the two center rows with a spindle picker. Data were subjected to ANOVA and means were separated using a protected LSD.

The vast majority of plant bugs present were immature tarnished plant bugs, although a few clouded plant bugs were also present. All insecticide treatments provided significant reduction in plant bug numbers compared with the untreated check at both evaluation timings ( Table 1 ). Orthene, Transform, and the higher rate of Dimethoate provided better control of plant bugs at 6 DATA than did Vydate. At 6 DATB, Orthene and the higher rate of Dimethoate significantly reduced plant bug numbers compared with Vydate and Transform. All insecticide treatments yielded more than the untreated check. Bidrin and Orthene treatments yielded more than either rate of Dimethoate. No phytotoxicity was observed with any treatment.


Numbers per 10 row ft

6 DATA
6 DATB
Treatment/formulationRate (lb AI/acre)TPB immatures Plant bug total aTPB immatures Plant bug total abSeed cotton (lbs/acre)
Dimethoate 4EC0.2513.75 bc14.25 bc3.75 bcd4.50 bc4228 b
Dimethoate 4EC0.5010.25 c11.75 c2.75 cd2.75 c4157 b
Bidrin 8EC0.5011.25 c13.25 bc3.75 bcd4.00 bc4550 a
Orthene 97S0.9710.50 c11.25 c2.25 d2.25 c4554 a
Transform 50WG0.0479.00 c11.00 c5.25 bc5.75 b4391 ab
Vydate 3.77F0.4721.00 bc22.00 b6.00 b6.25 b4315 ab
Untreated31.25 a33.00 a28.00 a28.75 a3502 c
P > F0.00100.00130.00010.00010.0001

Numbers per 10 row ft

6 DATA
6 DATB
Treatment/formulationRate (lb AI/acre)TPB immatures Plant bug total aTPB immatures Plant bug total abSeed cotton (lbs/acre)
Dimethoate 4EC0.2513.75 bc14.25 bc3.75 bcd4.50 bc4228 b
Dimethoate 4EC0.5010.25 c11.75 c2.75 cd2.75 c4157 b
Bidrin 8EC0.5011.25 c13.25 bc3.75 bcd4.00 bc4550 a
Orthene 97S0.9710.50 c11.25 c2.25 d2.25 c4554 a
Transform 50WG0.0479.00 c11.00 c5.25 bc5.75 b4391 ab
Vydate 3.77F0.4721.00 bc22.00 b6.00 b6.25 b4315 ab
Untreated31.25 a33.00 a28.00 a28.75 a3502 c
P > F0.00100.00130.00010.00010.0001

Column means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, P  > 0.05).

a Tarnished + clouded, adults + immatures.

b Data transformed due to unequal variances (log ( x  + 1)); nontransformed means presented.


Numbers per 10 row ft

6 DATA
6 DATB
Treatment/formulationRate (lb AI/acre)TPB immatures Plant bug total aTPB immatures Plant bug total abSeed cotton (lbs/acre)
Dimethoate 4EC0.2513.75 bc14.25 bc3.75 bcd4.50 bc4228 b
Dimethoate 4EC0.5010.25 c11.75 c2.75 cd2.75 c4157 b
Bidrin 8EC0.5011.25 c13.25 bc3.75 bcd4.00 bc4550 a
Orthene 97S0.9710.50 c11.25 c2.25 d2.25 c4554 a
Transform 50WG0.0479.00 c11.00 c5.25 bc5.75 b4391 ab
Vydate 3.77F0.4721.00 bc22.00 b6.00 b6.25 b4315 ab
Untreated31.25 a33.00 a28.00 a28.75 a3502 c
P > F0.00100.00130.00010.00010.0001

Numbers per 10 row ft

6 DATA
6 DATB
Treatment/formulationRate (lb AI/acre)TPB immatures Plant bug total aTPB immatures Plant bug total abSeed cotton (lbs/acre)
Dimethoate 4EC0.2513.75 bc14.25 bc3.75 bcd4.50 bc4228 b
Dimethoate 4EC0.5010.25 c11.75 c2.75 cd2.75 c4157 b
Bidrin 8EC0.5011.25 c13.25 bc3.75 bcd4.00 bc4550 a
Orthene 97S0.9710.50 c11.25 c2.25 d2.25 c4554 a
Transform 50WG0.0479.00 c11.00 c5.25 bc5.75 b4391 ab
Vydate 3.77F0.4721.00 bc22.00 b6.00 b6.25 b4315 ab
Untreated31.25 a33.00 a28.00 a28.75 a3502 c
P > F0.00100.00130.00010.00010.0001

Column means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, P  > 0.05).

a Tarnished + clouded, adults + immatures.

b Data transformed due to unequal variances (log ( x  + 1)); nontransformed means presented.

* This research was partially supported by industry gifts of pesticide and seed.

Author notes

Subject Editor: Jawwad Qureshi

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ ), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]