This experiment was conducted on lowbush blueberry to evaluate the effectiveness of five insecticides against blueberry tip midge (TM). Materials were applied to 7 × 20-ft plots in a vegetative-year blueberry field at Jonesboro, ME. There were four treated plots for each material plus four untreated check plots. All treatments were applied in 25 gal of water-mixture per acre using a CO 2 -propelled, 80-inch boom sprayer (76-inch swath), with four, flat spray 8002VS TeeJet nozzles operating at 35 psi. Rimon 0.83EC (novaluron), Movento SC (spirotetramat), Exirel SE (cyantraniliprole), Sivanto 200SL (flupyradifurone), and Assail 30SG (acetamiprid) were applied on 27 May. A second application of each material was made on 5 Jun. Blueberry stems were scattered and < 1 inch tall on 27 May and 1–1.5 inches tall on 5 Jun. Larval infestation was assessed on 12 and 25 Jun by counting the number of blueberry stems with and without tip midge damage as evidenced by curled leaves from each of three, sq ft samples per treated plot. No symptoms of phytotoxicity were apparent in any of the plots.

Analysis of Variance (ANOVA, RCB) and LSD ( P 0.05) were used to compare mean number of curls among the treatment plots. Subplots were pooled within main plots.

Data were transformed by arcsine to stabilize variance prior to analysis. Rimon, Exirel, Sivanto, and Assail were all effective, at least initially, in suppressing tip midge populations. Significantly fewer damaged stems were found in the treated plots compared with the non-treated checks on the first sample date on 12 Jun ( F(5,15,)  = 19.31 ,P  = < 0.0001). However, by the second sample date on 25 Jun numbers of damaged stems in the treated plots increased resulting in no significant difference in numbers of damaged stems in all treated plots compared with the non-treated checks; ( F(5,15)  = 0.56, P  = 0.7260) ( Table 1 ). This research was supported in part by industry gift(s) of pesticides and/or research funding.

Treatment/formulationRate product/acre Mean curls/ft 2
12 Jun25 Jun
Assail 30SG5.3 oz4.3 b6.8 a
Exirel SE6.0 oz2.7 b4.3 a
Movento SC10.0 oz5.1 a12.8 a
+ Dyne Amic(0.5% v/v)
Rimon 0.83EC12.0 oz3.4 b11.4 a
Sivanto 200SL14.0 oz6.4 b8.5 a
Non-treated check38.0 a5.3 a
Treatment/formulationRate product/acre Mean curls/ft 2
12 Jun25 Jun
Assail 30SG5.3 oz4.3 b6.8 a
Exirel SE6.0 oz2.7 b4.3 a
Movento SC10.0 oz5.1 a12.8 a
+ Dyne Amic(0.5% v/v)
Rimon 0.83EC12.0 oz3.4 b11.4 a
Sivanto 200SL14.0 oz6.4 b8.5 a
Non-treated check38.0 a5.3 a

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, P 0.05). Data were transformed by arcsine prior to analysis.

Treatment/formulationRate product/acre Mean curls/ft 2
12 Jun25 Jun
Assail 30SG5.3 oz4.3 b6.8 a
Exirel SE6.0 oz2.7 b4.3 a
Movento SC10.0 oz5.1 a12.8 a
+ Dyne Amic(0.5% v/v)
Rimon 0.83EC12.0 oz3.4 b11.4 a
Sivanto 200SL14.0 oz6.4 b8.5 a
Non-treated check38.0 a5.3 a
Treatment/formulationRate product/acre Mean curls/ft 2
12 Jun25 Jun
Assail 30SG5.3 oz4.3 b6.8 a
Exirel SE6.0 oz2.7 b4.3 a
Movento SC10.0 oz5.1 a12.8 a
+ Dyne Amic(0.5% v/v)
Rimon 0.83EC12.0 oz3.4 b11.4 a
Sivanto 200SL14.0 oz6.4 b8.5 a
Non-treated check38.0 a5.3 a

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, P 0.05). Data were transformed by arcsine prior to analysis.

Author notes

Subject Editor: John Wise

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ ), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]