Corn rootworm management efficacy trials were conducted to evaluate transgenic insect-resistant hybrids and granular insecticide combination treatments near Bryant and Cavour in South Dakota. The study was arranged in an RCBD with four ∼50 foot long replications. Four row treatments were established using rows that were spaced 30 inches apart at planting-time. In-furrow liquid insecticide treatments were placed directly into the open seed furrow between double-disk openers. The Agrisure3122- E-Z refuge and Agrisure Avicta (N29T3122), Agrisure Viptera (N29T-3111), and Agrisure CB (N92T43-3220) corn hybrids seeds were all treated with CruiserMaxx at 0.25 mg ( AI )/seed for secondary pest control. This seed was planted at ∼ 31,000 kernels per acre. Six roots per plot were dug randomly from the two outer rows, washed and rated using the Oleson 0–3 root injury rating scale. Yield assessments were taken from the center two rows. Yield and root rating data were analyzed by using SAS version 9.2 PROC MIXED/PDIFF option with Saxton’s lettering macro.

Root rating means from Agrisure CB that offered no NCR/WCR protection was 0.43, and 1.38 at Bryant and Cavour. Therefore rootworm pressures could be categorized as low to moderately high based on ∼0.25 economic injury level (EIL). Rootworm feeding pressure was ∼0.10 of a node greater at Bryant and 2/3 greater root injury at Cavour than in the previous season. In 2015, none of the rootworm toxin expressing hybrids allowed root feeding from rootworm larvae to exceed the ∼0.25 EIL. Insecticides are still very effective as a tool to reduce the feeding injury to corn roots.

Treatment/formulationRate Bryant
Cavour
Root ratingYield bu/acRoot ratingYield bu/ac
AgrisureCB0.43a162.6a1.38a125.2b
Agrisure3122 E-Z refuge0.06b156.9a0.04b164.8a
 Force 2.1CS a Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz 1000ft0.02b163.4a0.02b159.1ab
Agrisure 3000GT0.06b162.6a0.08b158.2ab
 Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz /1000ft0.02b160.3a0.03b152.0ab
 Capture LFR a0.49 Floz /1000ft0.04b159.1a0.06b153.2ab
P- values <0.00010.4018<0.0010.0510
Treatment/formulationRate Bryant
Cavour
Root ratingYield bu/acRoot ratingYield bu/ac
AgrisureCB0.43a162.6a1.38a125.2b
Agrisure3122 E-Z refuge0.06b156.9a0.04b164.8a
 Force 2.1CS a Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz 1000ft0.02b163.4a0.02b159.1ab
Agrisure 3000GT0.06b162.6a0.08b158.2ab
 Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz /1000ft0.02b160.3a0.03b152.0ab
 Capture LFR a0.49 Floz /1000ft0.04b159.1a0.06b153.2ab
P- values <0.00010.4018<0.0010.0510

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not significantly ( P > 0.05) different using SAS, version 9.2 PROC MIXED/PDIFF option with Saxton’s lettering macro. Hybrids were treated with CruiesrMax at 0.25 mg(Ai)/seed for secondary pest control.

a Liquid formulation delivered with a spray tip in-furrow placement.

Treatment/formulationRate Bryant
Cavour
Root ratingYield bu/acRoot ratingYield bu/ac
AgrisureCB0.43a162.6a1.38a125.2b
Agrisure3122 E-Z refuge0.06b156.9a0.04b164.8a
 Force 2.1CS a Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz 1000ft0.02b163.4a0.02b159.1ab
Agrisure 3000GT0.06b162.6a0.08b158.2ab
 Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz /1000ft0.02b160.3a0.03b152.0ab
 Capture LFR a0.49 Floz /1000ft0.04b159.1a0.06b153.2ab
P- values <0.00010.4018<0.0010.0510
Treatment/formulationRate Bryant
Cavour
Root ratingYield bu/acRoot ratingYield bu/ac
AgrisureCB0.43a162.6a1.38a125.2b
Agrisure3122 E-Z refuge0.06b156.9a0.04b164.8a
 Force 2.1CS a Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz 1000ft0.02b163.4a0.02b159.1ab
Agrisure 3000GT0.06b162.6a0.08b158.2ab
 Force 2.1CS a4.6 oz /1000ft0.02b160.3a0.03b152.0ab
 Capture LFR a0.49 Floz /1000ft0.04b159.1a0.06b153.2ab
P- values <0.00010.4018<0.0010.0510

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not significantly ( P > 0.05) different using SAS, version 9.2 PROC MIXED/PDIFF option with Saxton’s lettering macro. Hybrids were treated with CruiesrMax at 0.25 mg(Ai)/seed for secondary pest control.

a Liquid formulation delivered with a spray tip in-furrow placement.

Author notes

Subject Editor: Donald Cook

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ ), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]