Bemisia tabaci is a serious pest of several crops and causes a characteristic “silverleafing” on squash leaves which can cause a reduced yield and fruit quality. For this trial to evaluate its management using foliar sprays of insecticides, 3 raised beds 32 inches wide on 6-ft centers were prepared at the Southwest Florida Research and Education Center in Immokalee, FL. Beds were covered with white-on-black polyethylene. Plants were directly seeded by hand at 24-inch spacing on 26 September. Plots were assigned in an RCB design with 4 replications consisting of treatments and an untreated check plot with 15 plants in each single row plot and 5 plants between each plot acting as a spray buffer and pest reservoir. Foliar treatments were applied (Table 1) with a high clearance sprayer operating at 180 psi and 2.3 mph with delivery through 2 vertical booms, each equipped with 2 yellow Albuz hollow cone nozzles applying at a total volume of 40 gpa. Adult whitefly were counted weekly from 20 October to 17 November by carefully turning over 2 leaves on each of the 5 plants per plot. Whitefly nymphs were sampled on the same dates by collecting 1 lower leaf from each of the 5 plants per plot to count nymphs in the laboratory. Eight 0.5-inch2 discs were removed from each leaf using a cork borer and nymphs were counted on each under a stereoscopic microscope. Data were subjected to 1-way ANOVA and means separated using LSD (P = 0.05).

Rate/acre
Treatment/form.oz. form./Application dates
%vol/vol17-Oct24-Oct31-Oct7-Nov14-Nov
Untreated check
PQZ 1.87SC+2.4xx
Exirel 0.83SE+10xx
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12x
Cohere0.25%xxxxx
Barrett300.50%xxxxx
Barrett301%xxxxx
Barrett302%xxxxx
Rate/acre
Treatment/form.oz. form./Application dates
%vol/vol17-Oct24-Oct31-Oct7-Nov14-Nov
Untreated check
PQZ 1.87SC+2.4xx
Exirel 0.83SE+10xx
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12x
Cohere0.25%xxxxx
Barrett300.50%xxxxx
Barrett301%xxxxx
Barrett302%xxxxx

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
Treatment/form.oz. form./Application dates
%vol/vol17-Oct24-Oct31-Oct7-Nov14-Nov
Untreated check
PQZ 1.87SC+2.4xx
Exirel 0.83SE+10xx
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12x
Cohere0.25%xxxxx
Barrett300.50%xxxxx
Barrett301%xxxxx
Barrett302%xxxxx
Rate/acre
Treatment/form.oz. form./Application dates
%vol/vol17-Oct24-Oct31-Oct7-Nov14-Nov
Untreated check
PQZ 1.87SC+2.4xx
Exirel 0.83SE+10xx
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12x
Cohere0.25%xxxxx
Barrett300.50%xxxxx
Barrett301%xxxxx
Barrett302%xxxxx

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

All treatments significantly reduced the number of adult whitefly observed per leaf when compared to the untreated on all sample dates except for the PQZ rotation and Barrett30 at 1% on 20 October and the Barrett30 at 0.5% on 17 November (Table 2). Significant reduction in the number of whitefly eggs in all treatments compared to untreated checks was observed on 27 October and 9 November (Table 3). All treatments showed a reduction in egg numbers on those sample dates and without a significant difference between treatments. All treatments significantly reduced the number of nymphs counted on all sample dates compared to the untreated check with no significant differences observed among the treatments (Table 4). No phytotoxicity was observed.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of adult whitefly per leaf
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check0.88a1.30a5.80a1.68a1.45a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.40.85a0.08b1.60c0.48b0.38b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%0.38b0.25b2.13c0.85b1.03a
Barrett301%0.45ab0.43b4.18b0.75b0.40b
Barrett302%0.25b0.20b1.90c0.33b0.40b
P-Value0.0099<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of adult whitefly per leaf
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check0.88a1.30a5.80a1.68a1.45a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.40.85a0.08b1.60c0.48b0.38b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%0.38b0.25b2.13c0.85b1.03a
Barrett301%0.45ab0.43b4.18b0.75b0.40b
Barrett302%0.25b0.20b1.90c0.33b0.40b
P-Value0.0099<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of adult whitefly per leaf
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check0.88a1.30a5.80a1.68a1.45a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.40.85a0.08b1.60c0.48b0.38b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%0.38b0.25b2.13c0.85b1.03a
Barrett301%0.45ab0.43b4.18b0.75b0.40b
Barrett302%0.25b0.20b1.90c0.33b0.40b
P-Value0.0099<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of adult whitefly per leaf
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check0.88a1.30a5.80a1.68a1.45a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.40.85a0.08b1.60c0.48b0.38b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%0.38b0.25b2.13c0.85b1.03a
Barrett301%0.45ab0.43b4.18b0.75b0.40b
Barrett302%0.25b0.20b1.90c0.33b0.40b
P-Value0.0099<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly eggs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check6.4a1.2a0.95a1.00a0.8a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.43.2a0.3b0.15a0.25b0.05a
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%4.8a0.1b0.05a0.25b0.2a
Barrett301%3.8a0.3b0.05a0.00b0.45a
Barrett302%2.4a0.1b0.10a0.00b0.05a
P-Value0.08580.03830.20420.00590.1304
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly eggs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check6.4a1.2a0.95a1.00a0.8a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.43.2a0.3b0.15a0.25b0.05a
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%4.8a0.1b0.05a0.25b0.2a
Barrett301%3.8a0.3b0.05a0.00b0.45a
Barrett302%2.4a0.1b0.10a0.00b0.05a
P-Value0.08580.03830.20420.00590.1304

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly eggs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check6.4a1.2a0.95a1.00a0.8a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.43.2a0.3b0.15a0.25b0.05a
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%4.8a0.1b0.05a0.25b0.2a
Barrett301%3.8a0.3b0.05a0.00b0.45a
Barrett302%2.4a0.1b0.10a0.00b0.05a
P-Value0.08580.03830.20420.00590.1304
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly eggs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check6.4a1.2a0.95a1.00a0.8a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.43.2a0.3b0.15a0.25b0.05a
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%4.8a0.1b0.05a0.25b0.2a
Barrett301%3.8a0.3b0.05a0.00b0.45a
Barrett302%2.4a0.1b0.10a0.00b0.05a
P-Value0.08580.03830.20420.00590.1304

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly nymphs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check22.3a18.8a42.4a16.9a9.75a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.44.4b5.2b10.3b2.90b1.50b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%11.5b7.2b10.8b4.45b3.75b
Barrett301%10.5b8.6b15.5b3.10b3.35b
Barrett302%8.5b5.8b13.6b1.55b2.90b
P-Value0.00010.0007<0.0001<0.00010.0011
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly nymphs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check22.3a18.8a42.4a16.9a9.75a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.44.4b5.2b10.3b2.90b1.50b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%11.5b7.2b10.8b4.45b3.75b
Barrett301%10.5b8.6b15.5b3.10b3.35b
Barrett302%8.5b5.8b13.6b1.55b2.90b
P-Value0.00010.0007<0.0001<0.00010.0011

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly nymphs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check22.3a18.8a42.4a16.9a9.75a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.44.4b5.2b10.3b2.90b1.50b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%11.5b7.2b10.8b4.45b3.75b
Barrett301%10.5b8.6b15.5b3.10b3.35b
Barrett302%8.5b5.8b13.6b1.55b2.90b
P-Value0.00010.0007<0.0001<0.00010.0011
Rate/acre
oz. form./No. of whitefly nymphs per 4 square inches
Treatment/form.%vol/vol20-Oct27-Oct2-Nov9-Nov17-Nov
Untreated check22.3a18.8a42.4a16.9a9.75a
PQZ 1.87SC+2.44.4b5.2b10.3b2.90b1.50b
Exirel 0.83SE+10
Sivanto Prime 1.67SL+12
Cohere0.25%
Barrett300.50%11.5b7.2b10.8b4.45b3.75b
Barrett301%10.5b8.6b15.5b3.10b3.35b
Barrett302%8.5b5.8b13.6b1.55b2.90b
P-Value0.00010.0007<0.0001<0.00010.0011

Means within columns followed by same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

+ = The product with the plus sign and the product following the plus sign are all part of one treatment.

Acknowledgment

This research was supported by industry gifts of pesticide and funds.

Funding

None declared.

Conflicts of interest. None declared.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected] for reprints and translation rights for reprints. All other permissions can be obtained through our RightsLink service via the Permissions link on the article page on our site—for further information please contact [email protected].
Subject Editor: Mark Abney
Mark Abney
Subject Editor
Search for other works by this author on: