The efficacy of selected insecticides on lepidopteran pests of tomatoes was evaluated at the Virginia Tech Homefield Farm in Whitethorne, Virginia (Montgomery County). Tomatoes (Mountain Fresh) were transplanted on 9 June 2024. Plot size was 1 row by 20 ft grown on white plastic mulch with drip irrigation and no guard rows. Treatments were replicated four times in an RCB. All foliar treatments were applied with a single-nozzle boom equipped with 8003VS spray tip powered by a CO₂ backpack sprayer at 40 psi delivering 30 gpa. The applicator sprayed both sides of the staked row going up and down plants. All treatments included Dyne-Amic adjuvant at 0.25% v:v. All plots were treated weekly for 4 wk beginning at fruiting: 22 July (application 1), 29 July (application 2), 8 August (application 3), and 15 August (application 4). On 5 August and 20 August, full-sized but green or red tomato fruit were hand-harvested from plots and a sample of 30 fruit was examined for insect feeding damage. The number of fruits with lepidopteran chewing holes was recorded. All data were analyzed using analysis of variance procedures. Means were separated using Fisher’s LSD at the 0.05 level of significance. Data were sqrt transformed to normalize variance when necessary.

Lepidopteran pests included a mix of mostly 70% tomato fruitworm (Helicoverpa zea), 20% tobacco hornworm (Manduca sexta), and 10% yellowstriped armyworm (Spodoptera ornithogalli). Lepidopteran chewing damage to fruit averaged ~17% in the untreated check plots in the two harvests on 5 August and 20 August (Table 1). There was a significant treatment effect of this damage on both harvest dates. On 5 August, all insecticide treatments except Intrepid 2F had significantly less damage than the untreated check. On 20 August, all insecticide treatments had significantly less damage than the untreated check. No signs of phytotoxicity were observed.1

Rate/acre
(oz form.)
% lepidopteran damaged fruit
Treatment/Form.5 Aug20 Aug
Untreated check17.5 a16.8 a
Avaunt eVo3.474.3 b8.3 b
Avaunt eVo4.328.0 b7.5 b
Avaunt eVo5.235.0 b6.8 b
Coragen4.984.3 b2.5 b
Coragen7.505.8 b6.5 b
Intrepid 2F12.017.5 a9.3 b
ISM-555 SC200 (plinazolin)2.052.5 b4.3 b
Harvanta 50SL16.43.2 b2.5 b
P > F0.00510.0463
Rate/acre
(oz form.)
% lepidopteran damaged fruit
Treatment/Form.5 Aug20 Aug
Untreated check17.5 a16.8 a
Avaunt eVo3.474.3 b8.3 b
Avaunt eVo4.328.0 b7.5 b
Avaunt eVo5.235.0 b6.8 b
Coragen4.984.3 b2.5 b
Coragen7.505.8 b6.5 b
Intrepid 2F12.017.5 a9.3 b
ISM-555 SC200 (plinazolin)2.052.5 b4.3 b
Harvanta 50SL16.43.2 b2.5 b
P > F0.00510.0463

Means within columns followed by a common letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05, FPLSD).

All treatments included Dyne-Amic adjuvant at 0.25% v:v.

All data were analyzed using analysis of variance procedures.

Rate/acre
(oz form.)
% lepidopteran damaged fruit
Treatment/Form.5 Aug20 Aug
Untreated check17.5 a16.8 a
Avaunt eVo3.474.3 b8.3 b
Avaunt eVo4.328.0 b7.5 b
Avaunt eVo5.235.0 b6.8 b
Coragen4.984.3 b2.5 b
Coragen7.505.8 b6.5 b
Intrepid 2F12.017.5 a9.3 b
ISM-555 SC200 (plinazolin)2.052.5 b4.3 b
Harvanta 50SL16.43.2 b2.5 b
P > F0.00510.0463
Rate/acre
(oz form.)
% lepidopteran damaged fruit
Treatment/Form.5 Aug20 Aug
Untreated check17.5 a16.8 a
Avaunt eVo3.474.3 b8.3 b
Avaunt eVo4.328.0 b7.5 b
Avaunt eVo5.235.0 b6.8 b
Coragen4.984.3 b2.5 b
Coragen7.505.8 b6.5 b
Intrepid 2F12.017.5 a9.3 b
ISM-555 SC200 (plinazolin)2.052.5 b4.3 b
Harvanta 50SL16.43.2 b2.5 b
P > F0.00510.0463

Means within columns followed by a common letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05, FPLSD).

All treatments included Dyne-Amic adjuvant at 0.25% v:v.

All data were analyzed using analysis of variance procedures.

Footnotes

1

This research was supported in part by industry gifts of pesticides and/or research funding from FMC Corp., Summit Agro International, and Syngenta Crop Protection.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected] for reprints and translation rights for reprints. All other permissions can be obtained through our RightsLink service via the Permissions link on the article page on our site—for further information please contact [email protected].
Section Editor: John Palumbo
John Palumbo
Section Editor
Search for other works by this author on: