Fall armyworm (FAW) can be a destructive pest of sweet corn and can cause significant yield reduction by feeding on whorls, tassels, silks, and ears. This trial was conducted at the Southwest Florida Research and Education Center in Immokalee Florida on 3 beds, 32 inches wide and 400 ft long on 12 ft centers. Seeds were planted on 28 Sep at a 10-inch spacing. Five treatments and an untreated check were assigned in an RCB design with 4 replicates (Table 1). Each plot contained 35 plant spaces and 10 plants were used as buffers between plots. Applications were initiated on 27 Oct (Table 1) prior to the plants starting to push their tassels and were conducted with a high clearance sprayer moving at 2.3 mph equipped with 4 ceramic Albuz ‘yellow’ hollow cone tips each delivering 10 gpa at 180 psi for a total of 40 gpa. The nozzle location was adjusted to concentrate sprays on tassels, silks, or ears when appropriate to ensure larval exposure to spray material. Feeding damage rating was conducted on the whorls and tassels from 0 to 5; 0 = none, 1 < 5% damaged, 2: 6% to 33%, 3: 34% to 67%, and 4 > 68%. The visible larvae were counted on the whorls on 31 Oct and 7 Nov and on the tassels on 15 Nov. Ears were collected on 7 Dec. Damage to the cob was determined and grouped into 3 categories: no damage, tip damage, and ear damage. For the analysis, damage categories were combined, and ears were considered only as damaged or marketable. Data were analyzed using ANOVA, and differences among treatment means on each sampling date were determined using the LSD test (P = 0.05).

Table 1.

Application dates of the spray treatments.

Application dates
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce /acre40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA
27 Oct3 Nov16 Nov22 Nov29 Nov
Untreated check
Radiant SC6xxxxx
Coragen 1.67 SC6xxxxx
Besiege CS8xxxxx
Plemax SC3xxxxx
Plemax SC4xxxxx
Application dates
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce /acre40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA
27 Oct3 Nov16 Nov22 Nov29 Nov
Untreated check
Radiant SC6xxxxx
Coragen 1.67 SC6xxxxx
Besiege CS8xxxxx
Plemax SC3xxxxx
Plemax SC4xxxxx
Table 1.

Application dates of the spray treatments.

Application dates
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce /acre40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA
27 Oct3 Nov16 Nov22 Nov29 Nov
Untreated check
Radiant SC6xxxxx
Coragen 1.67 SC6xxxxx
Besiege CS8xxxxx
Plemax SC3xxxxx
Plemax SC4xxxxx
Application dates
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce /acre40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA40 GPA
27 Oct3 Nov16 Nov22 Nov29 Nov
Untreated check
Radiant SC6xxxxx
Coragen 1.67 SC6xxxxx
Besiege CS8xxxxx
Plemax SC3xxxxx
Plemax SC4xxxxx

FAW pressure was moderate in this trial, all damage observed is attributed to the FAW. Significantly less damage was found in all treatments on all sample dates when compared to the untreated check (Table 2), and significantly fewer larvae were observed in the plant whorls but not the tassels (Table 2).

Table 2.

Damage rating and larval counts.

Damage rating (0–5)No. larvae counted
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acreWhorlWhorlTasselWhorlWhorlTassel
31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov
Untreated check0.98a0.77a0.53a0.23a0.08a0.03a
Radiant SC60.23c0.10b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Coragen 1.67 SC60.17c0.27b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Besiege CS80.18c0.17b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC30.08c0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC40.48b0.20b0.02b0.02b0.00b0.00a
P-value<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.00010.0709
Damage rating (0–5)No. larvae counted
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acreWhorlWhorlTasselWhorlWhorlTassel
31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov
Untreated check0.98a0.77a0.53a0.23a0.08a0.03a
Radiant SC60.23c0.10b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Coragen 1.67 SC60.17c0.27b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Besiege CS80.18c0.17b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC30.08c0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC40.48b0.20b0.02b0.02b0.00b0.00a
P-value<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.00010.0709

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

Table 2.

Damage rating and larval counts.

Damage rating (0–5)No. larvae counted
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acreWhorlWhorlTasselWhorlWhorlTassel
31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov
Untreated check0.98a0.77a0.53a0.23a0.08a0.03a
Radiant SC60.23c0.10b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Coragen 1.67 SC60.17c0.27b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Besiege CS80.18c0.17b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC30.08c0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC40.48b0.20b0.02b0.02b0.00b0.00a
P-value<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.00010.0709
Damage rating (0–5)No. larvae counted
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acreWhorlWhorlTasselWhorlWhorlTassel
31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov31 Oct7 Nov15 Nov
Untreated check0.98a0.77a0.53a0.23a0.08a0.03a
Radiant SC60.23c0.10b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Coragen 1.67 SC60.17c0.27b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Besiege CS80.18c0.17b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC30.08c0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00b0.00a
Plemax SC40.48b0.20b0.02b0.02b0.00b0.00a
P-value<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001<0.00010.0709

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

All programs increased marketable yield and contained fewer FAW larvae at harvest when compared to the untreated (Table 3).

Table 3

Marketable ears and number of larvae found per 20 ears.

Marketable ears out of 20 collectedLarva found per 20 ears
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acre7 Dec7 Dec
Untreated check16.0a4.25a
Radiant SC619.75b0.50b
Coragen 1.67 SC619.0b0.75b
Besiege CS819.25b0.75b
Plemax SC319.0b2.0b
Plemax SC419.0b0.50b
P-value0.00070.0054
Marketable ears out of 20 collectedLarva found per 20 ears
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acre7 Dec7 Dec
Untreated check16.0a4.25a
Radiant SC619.75b0.50b
Coragen 1.67 SC619.0b0.75b
Besiege CS819.25b0.75b
Plemax SC319.0b2.0b
Plemax SC419.0b0.50b
P-value0.00070.0054

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

Table 3

Marketable ears and number of larvae found per 20 ears.

Marketable ears out of 20 collectedLarva found per 20 ears
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acre7 Dec7 Dec
Untreated check16.0a4.25a
Radiant SC619.75b0.50b
Coragen 1.67 SC619.0b0.75b
Besiege CS819.25b0.75b
Plemax SC319.0b2.0b
Plemax SC419.0b0.50b
P-value0.00070.0054
Marketable ears out of 20 collectedLarva found per 20 ears
Treatment/FormulationFluid ounce/acre7 Dec7 Dec
Untreated check16.0a4.25a
Radiant SC619.75b0.50b
Coragen 1.67 SC619.0b0.75b
Besiege CS819.25b0.75b
Plemax SC319.0b2.0b
Plemax SC419.0b0.50b
P-value0.00070.0054

Means within columns followed by the same letter are not statistically different (LSD, P > 0.05).

No phytotoxicity was observed.1

Footnotes

1

This research was supported by industry funding.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected] for reprints and translation rights for reprints. All other permissions can be obtained through our RightsLink service via the Permissions link on the article page on our site—for further information please contact [email protected].
Subject Editor: Mark Abne
Mark Abne
Subject Editor
Search for other works by this author on: